(a) The International Criminal Court (ICC)
Introduction
The International Criminal Court (ICC) is a permanent, independent judicial institution that prosecutes individuals for war crimes, genocide, crimes against humanity, and crimes of aggression. Established by the Rome Statute in 1998, the ICC plays a crucial role in ensuring that those responsible for serious crimes do not escape justice.
The ICC is headquartered in The Hague, Netherlands, and aims to hold powerful leaders accountable, provide justice for victims, and strengthen the global rule of law.
1. Objectives and Jurisdiction of the ICC
A. Prosecuting War Crimes and Human Rights Violations
- The ICC investigates and prosecutes individuals accused of genocide, mass killings, torture, sexual violence, and forced displacement.
- Example: Former Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir was charged with war crimes for his role in the Darfur genocide.
B. Universal Jurisdiction Over Serious Crimes
- The ICC has jurisdiction over member states of the Rome Statute and can investigate crimes committed on their territory.
- If a country is not a member, the ICC can still intervene if the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) refers a case.
C. Holding Political Leaders and Military Commanders Accountable
- Unlike national courts, the ICC can prosecute heads of state, military generals, and government officials.
- Example: The ICC indicted Muammar Gaddafi of Libya for crimes against humanity during the 2011 civil war.
2. Achievements of the ICC
- Issued arrest warrants for war criminals in Sudan, Uganda, the Democratic Republic of Congo, and the Central African Republic.
- Convicted individuals responsible for mass killings, rape, and child soldier recruitment.
- Provided justice for victims through legal proceedings and reparations.
3. Challenges Faced by the ICC
A. Lack of Universal Membership
- Some powerful countries, including the U.S., China, and Russia, are not members and do not recognize the ICC’s authority.
- Non-member states can refuse to cooperate with ICC investigations.
B. Political Bias Allegations
- The ICC has been accused of focusing too much on African nations while not prosecuting crimes committed by Western powers.
- Example: African leaders argue that the ICC unfairly targets their continent while ignoring crimes committed in Iraq and Afghanistan.
C. Enforcement Difficulties
- The ICC does not have its own police force and relies on national governments to arrest suspects.
- Many indicted individuals, like Joseph Kony (Ugandan warlord), remain at large.
4. Future of the ICC
- Expanding global participation by persuading more countries to ratify the Rome Statute.
- Strengthening cooperation with international organizations like the UN to enforce arrest warrants.
- Addressing concerns about fairness and political neutrality to improve its credibility.
(b) Dispute Resolution Mechanism of the WTO
Introduction
The World Trade Organization (WTO) is responsible for regulating global trade and ensuring that international trade flows smoothly and fairly. One of its most important functions is the Dispute Settlement Mechanism (DSM), which resolves trade disputes between member countries.
The WTO’s dispute resolution system is crucial for maintaining stability in global trade, preventing trade wars, and ensuring compliance with international trade agreements.
1. How the WTO Dispute Resolution Mechanism Works
A. Filing a Complaint
- If a country believes that another country is violating WTO trade rules, it can file a complaint.
- The complaint is reviewed by WTO dispute panels and legal experts.
- Example: The U.S. filed a complaint against China for unfair trade subsidies in 2012.
B. Consultation Phase
- The first step is negotiation—countries try to resolve the dispute through diplomatic talks.
- If negotiations fail, the case moves to a formal panel hearing.
C. Panel and Appellate Review
- A panel of trade experts examines the case and issues a ruling.
- If a country disagrees with the ruling, it can appeal to the WTO Appellate Body.
- Example: The EU and U.S. had a long dispute over subsidies for aircraft manufacturers Boeing and Airbus, which was settled through WTO mediation.
D. Enforcement of Rulings
- If a country is found guilty of violating trade laws, it must change its policies or face trade sanctions.
- The WTO allows the winning country to impose retaliatory tariffs if the losing country does not comply.
2. Importance of the WTO Dispute Settlement Mechanism
- Prevents trade wars by providing a structured system to handle disputes.
- Ensures fair trade practices, protecting smaller economies from unfair policies by larger nations.
- Strengthens the global economy by maintaining stable international trade relations.
3. Challenges in WTO Dispute Resolution
A. Delays in Settling Disputes
- Cases can take several years to resolve, which slows down the resolution process.
- Example: The U.S.-EU trade dispute over steel tariffs lasted for more than a decade.
B. Lack of Enforcement Power
- The WTO cannot force countries to comply with rulings, as it lacks a military or police force.
- Countries can ignore rulings if they are powerful enough to resist trade sanctions.
C. U.S. Blockade of the Appellate Body
- Since 2019, the U.S. has blocked the appointment of new judges to the WTO’s Appellate Body.
- This has effectively paralyzed the dispute resolution process, as there are not enough judges to hear appeals.
4. Future of WTO Dispute Resolution
- Reforming the system to speed up dispute resolutions and reduce case backlogs.
- Encouraging the U.S. and other major powers to support WTO reforms.
- Strengthening enforcement mechanisms to ensure compliance with trade rulings.
Conclusion
The International Criminal Court (ICC) plays a critical role in prosecuting war crimes and crimes against humanity, but it faces challenges like lack of universal support and enforcement issues. To be more effective, the ICC needs greater global cooperation and neutrality in its cases.
The WTO Dispute Settlement Mechanism is essential for maintaining fair trade practices, but it faces delays, enforcement problems, and political blockages. Reforming the WTO’s dispute system will be crucial for ensuring the stability of the global economy in the future.
For More Political Science Assignment Questions, Visit:
For more political science assignment questions visit
To search other questions, visit
To see the assignment questions, visit