1. Analyse the politics of water disputes among Indian states and their impact.

Politics of Water Disputes Among Indian States and Their Impact

Introduction

Water disputes in India have been a longstanding issue due to the country’s federal structure, where rivers often flow through multiple states. The unequal distribution of water resources, growing demand, and political interests have resulted in frequent conflicts among states. These disputes significantly impact interstate relations, economic development, and the well-being of millions dependent on these water bodies for livelihood.

Major Water Disputes in India

Several inter-state river disputes have emerged over the years, leading to legal and political battles. Some of the most prominent disputes include:

1. Cauvery Water Dispute (Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Kerala, and Puducherry)
   • The dispute originated due to differing demands and usage patterns of the Cauvery River, mainly between Tamil Nadu and Karnataka.
   • The Supreme Court and Cauvery Water Management Authority (CWMA) have attempted to regulate water sharing, but tensions persist.
2. Krishna River Dispute (Maharashtra, Karnataka, Telangana, and Andhra Pradesh)
   • The river, a lifeline for these states, has seen multiple disputes regarding allocation.
   • The Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal (KWDT) has given verdicts, yet disagreements continue.
3. Godavari River Dispute (Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Maharashtra, Odisha, and Chhattisgarh)
   • Conflicts arise due to projects such as the Polavaram Dam and allocation of water among upper and lower riparian states.
4. Yamuna River Dispute (Haryana, Uttar Pradesh, Delhi, and Rajasthan)
   • Affected by excessive demand for drinking and irrigation purposes, this dispute mainly concerns Delhi and Haryana.
5. Narmada Water Dispute (Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat, Maharashtra, and Rajasthan)
   • The conflict revolves around the allocation of water from the Narmada River, particularly the Sardar Sarovar Dam project.

Causes of Water Disputes

The following are the key reasons behind the recurring water disputes:

1. Federal Structure and State Interests
   • Water is a state subject under the Constitution, but inter-state rivers fall under the Union’s jurisdiction. This creates tensions between the central government and states.
2. Unequal Distribution of Water
   • Some states have abundant water resources, while others struggle with scarcity, leading to disputes over water-sharing agreements.
3. Increasing Demand for Water
   • Rapid urbanization, industrialization, and agricultural expansion have intensified competition for water.
4. Failure of Water Tribunals
   • Although tribunals like the Inter-State Water Disputes Act (1956) aim to resolve conflicts, their slow functioning and legal battles often delay resolutions.
5. Climatic and Environmental Factors
   • Climate change, erratic monsoons, and deforestation have impacted river water levels, leading to additional disputes.

Impact of Water Disputes

Water disputes among Indian states have multiple consequences, affecting governance, society, and the economy.

1. Political Tensions and Regionalism
   • Water disputes fuel regionalism, with states prioritizing their interests over national unity. This often leads to political protests and unrest.
2. Economic Consequences
   • Industries and agriculture suffer when water is scarce or uncertain. Farmers dependent on river water face significant losses, impacting food production.
3. Legal and Constitutional Challenges
   • Disputes lead to prolonged legal battles, burdening the judiciary and delaying justice.
4. Social Unrest and Protests
   • Water conflicts have triggered violent protests, such as the Cauvery riots in Karnataka and Tamil Nadu.
5. Environmental Degradation
   • Over-extraction of river water and construction of large dams have led to ecological imbalances, loss of biodiversity, and groundwater depletion.
6. Interference of Central Government
   • Disputes often lead to increased central intervention, creating friction between states and the Union government.

Efforts to Resolve Water Disputes

The government has taken several measures to mitigate water conflicts:

1. Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956
   • Provides mechanisms for setting up tribunals to resolve disputes.
2. National Water Policy (2012)
   • Advocates sustainable water management and encourages states to resolve conflicts amicably.
3. River Basin Management Approach
   • Promotes the concept of treating rivers as a collective resource rather than as state-owned entities.
4. Technology and Water Conservation
   • Promoting rainwater harvesting, interlinking rivers, and using efficient irrigation techniques to minimize conflicts.

Conclusion

Water disputes among Indian states are complex and deeply rooted in history, geography, and politics. Resolving them requires cooperative federalism, legal reforms, and sustainable water management. Only through dialogue, negotiation, and effective policies can India ensure equitable water distribution and long-term peace among states.

---

For more political science assignment questions visit: IGNOU MA Political Science Assignments
To search other questions, visit: IGNOU Solved Assignments
To see the assignment questions, visit: IGNOU Official Assignment PDF