Introduction
The Prohibition Movement refers to social and political efforts to ban the production, sale, and consumption of alcohol. This movement has been driven by concerns over health, morality, crime, and social welfare. Across the world, prohibition has been implemented in various countries at different times, with varying levels of success and failure.
In India, the prohibition movement has been deeply influenced by Mahatma Gandhi, who saw alcohol consumption as a social evil that harmed families and communities. Several Indian states have implemented alcohol bans over the years, but the policy remains highly controversial due to its economic, social, and political impacts.
This essay examines the history, impact, and challenges of prohibition, particularly in the Indian context.
1. Origins of the Prohibition Movement
A. Global History of Prohibition
- The Temperance Movement in the United States and Europe (19th century) advocated for alcohol bans, linking it to crime and moral decay.
- Prohibition in the USA (1920-1933):
- The 18th Amendment banned alcohol but led to a rise in illegal liquor trade (bootlegging) and organized crime.
- It was repealed by the 21st Amendment in 1933 due to economic and enforcement failures.
B. Prohibition Movement in India
1. Gandhi’s Role in Prohibition
- Gandhi strongly opposed alcohol, calling it a social evil that harmed families, the economy, and moral values.
- He believed that liquor led to:
- Poverty and financial ruin among the poor.
- Domestic violence and crime.
- Moral degradation and corruption.
- Quote by Gandhi:
“Alcohol makes a man forget himself, his responsibilities, and his duty towards his family and society.”
2. Role of the Women’s Movement in Prohibition
- Women played a major role in prohibition campaigns, especially in rural India.
- Example: In Andhra Pradesh (1990s), women-led protests forced the government to impose prohibition in some areas.
3. Constitutional Provision on Prohibition
- Article 47 of the Indian Constitution states that:
- “The state shall endeavor to bring about prohibition of the consumption of intoxicating drinks and drugs which are injurious to health.”
- However, prohibition is a state subject, meaning each Indian state can choose its own alcohol policy.
2. Impact of the Prohibition Movement in India
A. States with Prohibition Laws
Several Indian states have implemented partial or full prohibition, including:
| State | Prohibition Status |
|---|---|
| Gujarat | Full prohibition since 1960. |
| Bihar | Full ban on liquor since 2016. |
| Nagaland | Prohibition since 1989, but with black market issues. |
| Mizoram | Prohibition lifted in 2014 due to economic losses. |
| Tamil Nadu | Partial prohibition; alcohol sale is state-controlled. |
B. Positive Impacts of Prohibition
- Reduction in Crime and Domestic Violence
- Studies show that alcohol bans reduce domestic violence and crime rates.
- Example: After Bihar’s prohibition law in 2016, domestic violence complaints decreased.
- Improved Health Outcomes
- Reducing alcohol consumption lowers liver disease, addiction rates, and road accidents.
- Better Family Financial Stability
- Poor households save more money when men do not spend on alcohol.
- Example: Studies in Gujarat show higher savings and better health in prohibition-enforced areas.
- Religious and Cultural Support for Prohibition
- Many Indian communities support prohibition due to religious beliefs (Hinduism, Islam, Jainism).
- Example: The Bishnoi community in Rajasthan follows a strict alcohol-free lifestyle.
C. Negative Impacts of Prohibition
- Rise of Illegal Alcohol Trade (Black Market)
- Prohibition often leads to illegal production and smuggling of alcohol.
- Example: Gujarat has a thriving black market for liquor, despite strict prohibition laws.
- Loss of Government Revenue
- The alcohol industry contributes thousands of crores in tax revenue to state governments.
- Example: Tamil Nadu earns ₹33,811 crore per year from liquor sales.
- States like Mizoram and Haryana lifted prohibition due to financial losses.
- Health Risks from Spurious Liquor
- Prohibition often increases consumption of illicit liquor, leading to mass poisoning incidents.
- Example:
- Bihar (2018) – Over 40 people died from consuming illicit alcohol.
- Gujarat (2022) – More than 50 deaths due to toxic homemade liquor.
- Unemployment in Alcohol-Dependent Industries
- Millions of people depend on liquor production, sales, and distribution for employment.
- Example: The Bihar liquor ban caused job losses for thousands of workers in the alcohol industry.
3. Challenges in Implementing Prohibition
| Challenge | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Enforcement Issues | Hard to monitor smuggling and illegal trade. |
| Revenue Loss | Governments lose billions in liquor tax revenue. |
| Corruption and Political Influence | Liquor mafias bribe officials to continue illegal sales. |
| Lack of Public Support | Many people oppose bans, leading to violations. |
4. The Way Forward: Alternatives to Total Prohibition
Since total prohibition has both benefits and drawbacks, some alternative solutions can be considered:
- Strict Alcohol Regulation Instead of Total Ban
- The government can control sales, limit hours, and impose high taxes instead of banning alcohol completely.
- Example: Kerala has reduced alcohol availability through partial prohibition and high liquor taxes.
- Public Awareness Campaigns
- Educating people about the dangers of excessive drinking can reduce consumption.
- Example: The “Alcohol-Free Villages” campaign in Maharashtra promotes self-imposed prohibition.
- Rehabilitation and De-Addiction Programs
- More investment in rehabilitation centers and addiction counseling can help problem drinkers.
- Example: Tamil Nadu runs alcohol de-addiction camps for those affected by alcoholism.
- Stronger Action Against Illicit Liquor Trade
- Police and administration should crack down on illegal alcohol production and smuggling.
- Example: Bihar strengthened law enforcement after the rise of illegal liquor sales.
5. Conclusion
The Prohibition Movement remains a complex issue in India, balancing social welfare with economic concerns. While prohibition can reduce alcohol-related harm, it also leads to illegal trade, revenue loss, and enforcement challenges.
Instead of total prohibition, a more practical approach would be strict regulation, public awareness, and better alcohol management policies. This would allow states to protect health and social well-being while minimizing economic and enforcement difficulties.
For More Political Science and Gandhian Thought Assignment Questions, Visit:
For more political science assignment questions visit
To search other questions, visit
To see the assignment questions, visit